A federal lawsuit filed by the estate of Deshayla Harris alleges that she was killed during the same March 26, 2021, Oceanfront shootings under chaotic conditions that police failed to control. The complaint claims the shooter remains unidentified nearly two years later and raises the possibility that a police officer may have fired the fatal shot.

The filing further alleges failures by Virginia Beach police to secure the scene, provide guidance to civilians, or release key evidence—including ballistics reports and body camera footage—leaving critical questions about responsibility unresolved.

This complaint ties directly into the broader Lynch case by highlighting a second death the same night, raising overlapping questions about police actions, accountability, and missing evidence across both incidents.

Facts About the Night of March 26, 2021

Crowd, Conditions, and Police Presence

• The Oceanfront was unusually crowded—estimated at 300% above normal levels.
• Only about 12 police officers were assigned to the area.
• It was the first warm Friday night after COVID restrictions eased, contributing to large crowds.

Sequence of Events

• Multiple shootings occurred that night—at least three separate incidents.
• Police responded around 11:20 p.m. to initial gunfire.
• Officers allegedly:
  • Failed to establish a command post
  • Failed to secure the scene
  • Failed to create a safety zone or direct civilians

Deshayla Harris’s Movements

• She arrived around 10:30 p.m. with friends.
• After initial chaos, she and friends attempted to leave the area for safety.
• Around 11:48 p.m., they reached the area near 19th Street and Pacific Avenue.

The Shooting

• Gunfire erupted again as Harris and her friends tried to leave.
• They took cover in bushes during the chaos.
• Harris was struck by a single bullet to the back of the head.
• She was unarmed, not a suspect, and attempting to flee.

Police Conduct Allegations

• Officers allegedly:
  • Did not issue warnings before firing
  • Did not identify themselves
  • Fired into a crowded area

Medical Response

• Police initially checked for a pulse and applied gauze.
• EMS later arrived and pronounced her dead at the scene around 12:05 a.m.

---

Key Facts About Donovon Lynch (From This Complaint)

• Confirms that Officer Solomon Simmons III fired multiple rounds, killing Donovon Lynch that same night.
• Establishes both deaths as part of the same broader incident and environment.

---

Investigation & Aftermath Issues

Unidentified Shooter

• Nearly two years later, the shooter who killed Harris remained unidentified.
• Complaint suggests the shooter may have been a police officer, but this was not confirmed.

Ballistics Evidence Withheld

• The City allegedly refused to release the ballistics report despite repeated requests.
• This report is described as critical to determining whether a police weapon was involved.

Body Camera & Evidence Issues

• Police allegedly:
  • Withheld body camera footage (over 25 hours)
  • Withheld additional investigative records
• No bodycam footage of the actual shooting has been publicly released.

Transparency Concerns

• Plaintiff alleges:
  • FOIA requests were delayed or denied
  • Police controlled all key evidence
  • Information was withheld for years

Police Operational Failures (Alleged)

• Failure to:
  • Properly staff the area
  • Control the scene
  • Direct civilians to safety
  • Prevent escalation after initial shooting

Additional Controversial Allegations

• Plaintiff alleges:
  • Delayed or inadequate notification of Harris’s death
  • Confiscation and return of her phone with deleted content
  • Lack of support for the family after the incident

---

Core Takeaways for the Lynch Case Site

• The complaint provides a second, detailed narrative of the same night, independent of the Lynch case.
• It reinforces that:
  • The scene was chaotic and poorly controlled
  • Multiple shootings overlapped
  • Civilians were left without direction or protection
• It introduces a major unresolved issue:
  • A second fatal shooting with no identified shooter
• It raises serious questions about:
  • Police conduct during the incident
  • Evidence transparency after the fact
  • Whether additional police gunfire contributed to deaths that night